Hendrik van den Berg - Growth theory after Keynes, part II: 75 years of obstruction by the mainstream economics culture

jpe:10659 - Journal of Philosophical Economics, May 20, 2014, Volume VII Issue 2 - https://doi.org/10.46298/jpe.10659
Growth theory after Keynes, part II: 75 years of obstruction by the mainstream economics cultureArticle

Authors: Hendrik van den Berg 1

Part I of this essay explained the sequence of events that enabled the neoclassical paradigm to regain its dominant position in mainstream economics following serious challenges by ‘Keynesian’ economists. This second essay seeks to answer the question of why the economics profession was so willing to sustain the neoclassical paradigm in the face of the reality-based challenges by ‘Keynesian’ economists like Harrod and Domar. The answer is sought in the culture of economics, the history of science in general, and the study of power in the field of political economy. This article draws heavily on the work of the French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu, who divides culture into habitus (procedures and dispositions) and doxa (more abstract beliefs and philosophies), in order to provide insight into how culture affects economic thinking. Bourdieu’s concept of symbolic violence helps to explain how a narrower neoclassical growth model was enthusiastically accepted as a replacement for the ‘Keynesian’ Harrod-Domar growth model. Financial and business interests clearly understood the power of culture and they used their accumulated wealth to support the neoliberal doxa and neoclassical habitus that would induce economists to willingly provide intellectual cover for policies that benefitted those financial and business interests. We conclude with a discussion on how the history of thought on economic development might have evolved if the Keynesian paradigm, and its dynamic Harrod-Domar model, had prevailed.


Volume: Volume VII Issue 2
Section: Articles
Published on: May 20, 2014
Imported on: December 28, 2022
Keywords: Bourdieu,Harrod-Domar,sociology of economics,[SHS]Humanities and Social Sciences

Consultation statistics

This page has been seen 188 times.
This article's PDF has been downloaded 200 times.